Yuhong Holding Group Co.,LTD
A typical field scenario illustrates the point. A batch of 316L heat exchanger tubes developed rust spots on the shell side four months after commissioning. The customer's first reaction was that the grade was wrong. We looked at three places on site: heat tint still visible in the weld heat-affected zone, free iron left behind by grinding near the flange sealing face, and residual acid trapped in the tube-to-tubesheet expansion joint. None of the three was a material problem — all three were surface condition, and the material certificate was valid. The fault sat entirely outside what the certificate covers.
During welding, hot working or heat treatment without protective atmosphere, the surface forms an oxide scale — and beneath it, a chromium-depleted layer. Both must be removed before the part can develop its designed corrosion resistance. Pickling and passivation are the two processes that do it, and they are also the two steps most often certified rather than actually performed.
At high temperature, the alloying elements migrate to the surface and oxidise. The scale contains iron, chromium, nickel, molybdenum and silicon oxides, varying with grade and process. Two layers matter:
Fabrication can also deposit free iron on the surface — from grinding discs, tooling, lifting equipment or carbon steel contact. Free iron is a separate problem from heat tint: it rusts on its own and initiates pitting in the stainless beneath it.
A residual scale island, a chromium-depleted patch or a free-iron particle creates a local electrochemical cell. The contaminated spot becomes the anode and corrodes; the surrounding passive surface becomes the cathode. Pitting starts at that spot and penetrates the wall. A heat-tinted weld can therefore fail in chloride service on fully compliant material.
Pickling removes the oxide scale and the chromium-depleted layer beneath it, exposing clean, active metal. It is a chemical dissolution process, not a cleaning step, and it is controlled by the acid system and the process route.
Passivation forms a thin, chromium-rich oxide film on a clean surface. It does not remove scale or free iron — it only rebuilds the passive film where the surface is already clean. Passivation over a heat-tinted or contaminated surface produces a film over the contamination and the corrosion resistance remains compromised.
The sequence is therefore fixed: remove contamination first, then passivate. The standards that govern the two steps are ASTM A380 for cleaning and descaling practice and ASTM A967 for chemical passivation.
A 316L weld that rusts is not evidence that 316L was the wrong grade. It is evidence that the surface was never put into the condition the grade requires.
On our own pickling and passivation line, heat tint on welds is mechanically removed before pickling, every part is blue-spot tested after pickling, and nothing leaves the workshop without passing.
Why does a 304 or 316 weld rust if the material certificate is correct?
The certificate confirms the chemistry of the base metal and filler, not the surface condition. Oxide scale, a chromium-depleted layer or free iron on the finished weld can initiate pitting even when the material is fully compliant.
Can passivation remove heat tint from a weld?
No. Passivation builds a passive film on a clean surface but cannot dissolve heat tint or a chromium-depleted layer. Heat tint must be removed by pickling or mechanical cleaning before passivation.
Does pickling always need to be followed by passivation?
In most specifications, yes. Pickling leaves the surface clean and active; passivation rebuilds the chromium oxide film. Some combined pickle-passivate processes do both in one step under a qualified procedure.
Which standards cover pickling and passivation?
ASTM A380 covers cleaning and descaling of stainless steel; ASTM A967 covers chemical passivation. The purchase order should state the required surface condition and test method, not only the standard number.
![]()
![]()
Contact Person: Mr. Jikin Cai
Tel: +86-13819835483
Fax: 0086-574-88017980